Interference with custody, also known as custodial interference, occurs when a parent or third party violates a court-ordered custody agreement, either directly or indirectly, which can result in legal repercussions. Violation of lawful custody rights is considered a criminal offense and can result in imprisonment in all states. Strategies for avoiding and addressing interference with custody may include attempting to resolve differences through dialogue, engaging a mediator, and consulting with a legal professional.
By understanding the different types of interference with custody, parents can better navigate the challenges of co-parenting and protect their child’s best interests. Let’s explore the direct and indirect forms of custody interference in more detail.
Direct Interference with Custody
Direct interference with custody can include physically obstructing visitation, not returning the child, relocating the child without authorization, and annulling visitation time, which can lead to legal consequences. Examples of direct interference with custody include physically preventing visitation, refusing to return the child, moving the child without permission, and canceling visitation time by one or her parents.
If one or both parents believe there are valid grounds to alter the parenting time order, it is recommended that they file a motion in court. It is also advised that they seek legal advice before making any changes to the parenting time schedule independently.
Indirect Interference with Custody
Indirect parenting time interference involves disrupting communication, preventing participation in activities, disparaging the other parent, and encouraging the child to refuse visits. For example, parents may overbook their child to be in extra curriculars constantly, preventing them from seeing the other parents. While this is not necessarily illegal in criminal cases, it can be used to find contempt of court in family law.
In severe cases, contacting law enforcement may be necessary to address the interference. Refusal to permit a child to contact the non-custodial parent via telephone and hindering a parent from engaging in a child’s educational or extracurricular activities may be viewed as unacceptable interference with custody.
Penalties and Consequences of Interference with Custody
Penalties and consequences of interference with custody can range from civil to criminal, depending on the severity of the violation and the jurisdiction. The laws in each state and the details of the case can significantly influence the charges imposed.
Violating a court order pertaining to custody may lead to legal repercussions, and the court may modify the current rights based on the presented evidence.
Criminal Examples in Illinois Law
In Illinois, for example, a parent can be fined and have varying consequences in the instance of criminal cases.
- the first two offenses result in a $500 fine
- Any more offenses after that are considered a class A misdemeanor punishable by:
- up to 1 year in jail
- a fine up to $2500
Civil Examples in Illinois Law
In the instance of civil cases, the court may hold the offending parent in indirect civil contempt of court. In addition to that, the judge may have other remedies that include:
- making up missed visitation and revising the previous custody order and visitation schedule
- offending parent or both parents required to go to parenting classes
- offending parent or both parents required to go to counseling
- fines
- any expenses like attorney fees and babysitting costs to be reimbursed by the offending parent
Proving Interference with Custody
To prove interference with custody, the affected party must demonstrate the violator’s intent and knowledge, as well as provide evidence and documentation of the violation. Court-ordered custody rights must be established, violation of those rights must be shown, knowledge and intent must be proven, and documentation and evidence must be presented.
Understanding the requirements for proving interference with custody is crucial for parents involved in custody disputes to protect their rights and ensure the best interests of the child are maintained. Let’s delve deeper into the aspects of intent and knowledge, as well as evidence and documentation.
Intent and Knowledge
Intent and knowledge refer to the violator’s cognizance of the custody agreement and their intentional actions to contravene it. The significance of intent and knowledge when demonstrating interference with custody is that it showcases the individual’s mindset and cognizance of their conduct. Intent alludes to the purpose or motive behind the interference, while knowledge alludes to being mindful that the activities are intruding on the custodial rights of another person. Demonstrating intent and knowledge is essential in showing that the interference was intentional and not inadvertent, which is expected from a committed person.
Examples of intent and knowledge include a parent taking a child out of state without the other parent’s authorization or a parent declining to grant the other parent visitation rights.
Evidence and Documentation
Evidence and documentation can include records of missed visitation, canceled activities, and disrupted communication. Records of missed visits may include emails, text messages, and other forms of communication. Available records for canceled activities may include emails, text messages, and other forms of communication that document the canceled activities. Available records to document disrupted communication include emails, text messages, and other forms of communication.
By documenting instances of interference with custody, parents can strengthen their case and ensure that their rights, as well as the best interests of the child, are protected.
Penalties and Consequences of Interference with Custody
Penalties and consequences of interference with custody can range from civil to criminal, depending on the severity of the violation and the jurisdiction.The laws in each state and the details of the case can significantly influence the charges imposed.
Violating a court order pertaining to custody may lead to legal repercussions, and the court may modify the current rights based on the presented evidence.
Valid Defenses
Valid defenses may include unclear custody agreement terms, lack of intent or knowledge, concerns for the child’s safety, and the child being of legal age. An example of an unclear custody agreement term is when the agreement does not explicitly state who has the authority to make decisions regarding the child’s care or education.
An illustration of a lack of intent or knowledge is when an offending parent is unaware that their behavior is impeding the other parent’s custody rights. It could be indicative of a potential risk to the child’s safety if a parent perceives that the other parent is not providing a secure environment for the child.
By being aware of the valid defenses against interference with custody, parents can better protect their rights and ensure the best interests of the child are maintained.
Preventing and Addressing Interference with Custody
Preventing and addressing interference with custody can involve effective communication strategies, mediation, and conflict resolution to maintain a healthy co-parenting relationship and protect the child’s best interests. Mediation and conflict resolution can provide a safe and neutral space for parents to discuss their issues and come to an agreement that is in the best interests of the child, thereby helping to prevent and address interference with custody.
By employing effective strategies to prevent and address interference with custody, parents can promote a positive co-parenting relationship and ensure the well-being of their child.
Communication Strategies
Communication strategies refer to the approaches used to ensure that all parties involved in a custody dispute are aware of and comply with the expectations set forth. This may include engaging in open dialogue, setting clear expectations, and documenting agreements to avoid potential misunderstandings and disputes.
Open dialogue is a communication strategy that emphasizes having honest and respectful conversations between the parties involved in a custody dispute. It is essential to ensure that all parties have an opportunity to express their perspectives and that their opinions are valued.
By employing effective communication strategies, parents can avoid misunderstandings and disputes that may lead to interference with custody, ensuring a positive co-parenting relationship and the best interests of the child.
Mediation and Conflict Resolution
Mediation and conflict resolution is a process of resolving disputes through the assistance of a neutral third party, such as a mediator or family law attorney, to facilitate discussions and identify viable solutions. Various mediation strategies can be employed to prevent interference with custody, such as collaborative negotiation between co-parents, telephone mediation to reduce time and expenses, avoiding negative language and refraining from putting down the other parent or family members, and active listening without arguing or interrupting the other parent during mediation sessions.
By utilizing mediation and conflict resolution, parents can work together to resolve issues related to custody interference, maintain a healthy co-parenting relationship, and protect the best interests of the child. For more information, check out, Preparing For Child Custody Mediation - What You Need To Know.
While we serve most of Illinois, if you’re in the Tinley Park, IL area and are looking for an experienced child custody attorney to assist you, please feel free to reach out to O’Flaherty Law at:
16557 Oak Park Ave., Ste. B,
Tinley Park, IL 60477
(708) 894-3030
https://www.oflaherty-law.com/areas-of-law/tinley-park-attorneys
.avif)
.svg){kind=small}
